Making Healthy Relationship Choices After Severe Trauma

We all need connection. Interdependence, mutualstate of helplessness, in which all verbal
relationships are crucial for our well being. However,communication seems futile. A return to earlier coping
for those who have experienced severe childhoodmechanisms, such as self-blame, numbing (by means
trauma, relationships were also the source ofof emotional withdrawal or drugs or alcohol), and
betrayal, wounding and abuse. What does this meanphysical violence sets the stage for a repetition of
then for those who have been severely abused bythe childhood trauma and "return of the repressed." [I
parents or caretakers as children? Or those whowould add to this another form of "numbing":
have dissociated, losing awareness of some aspectsdissociation!]
of early relationships? For example, those withWhat does this mean? Too often survivors hear this
dissociative identity disorder (DID) may have someas more condemnation of themselves, as proof
parts of their system who only know about thesomehow that there is something innately "bad"
"good mother" while others hold the memories ofabout them causing others to behave abusively. I
abuse and/or neglect. In this way, dissociation canwant to emphasize strongly that this is not my
make evaluating who is healthy or safe and who isexperience or how I understand this information.
not more difficult. This results in obvious and multipleI see the "repetition compulsion" as an unconscious
complications in forming and maintaining laterattempt to master that which went so awry, early
relationships.abusive relationships. Like imago relationship theory
Some types of relationship difficulties clients of minesuggests, we all function this way. We all seek to
describe fairly often include:rework the ways we were wounded. The problem
- Feeling so wounded and mistrustful of people inarises when those early experiences were severely
general it doesn't feel worth the risk to attemptabusive, leading us to pick another abuser.
connections. This results in extreme isolation andAnother piece of this puzzle involves understanding
loneliness.the dynamics of abusers. Many abusers are good at
- The belief or fear that there is something so "bad"selecting "victims". By that I mean that they can
about oneself that it will harm/destroy anyone yousense who is vulnerable. I believe many abusers test
get close to.and see how far they can push boundaries and pick
- Premature attaching to others, disclosing sensitive/apartners who will not notice early boundary violations
great deal of information about oneself beforeor control tactics. Dissociation, the very thing that is
assessing how safe a choice the other is.life saving in childhood, can make you more vulnerable
- Inability to fully assess potential friends andas an adult. How do you make good relationship
romantic partners due to dissociation. Missing "redchoices if you do not have access to all the
flags" due to dissociation, different parts holdinginformation about people in your life? Many clients
information.with DID have described to me having no awareness
- Experiencing kind, safe, gentle people/relationshipsof the abusive behavior of current people in their life.
as boring, undesirable or frightening.Only later would we unravel that they were switching
- Sabotaging relationships (for example picking a fight)to different parts (those used to handling such
when things are going smoothly or feeling "too" close.things) prior to a friend or partner starting to behave
This may be a way to get distance, push away orin a way that was borderline abusive. If this
about seeing what happens. For example, if a friendinformation is split off it can impact your decision
or partner (or therapist) gets angry at you, will theymaking and safety.
become violent or abusive like childhood figures did?So what can you do? The answer really isn't to avoid
- Extreme care taking or people pleasing. Do you feelpeople altogether. Learning that not all relationships
like you must suppress your needs/feelings in theare like your early abusive ones is an important part
service of taking care of others? Do you feel likeof the healing process. How can you work on making
you must shift who you are in order to be lovedinformed relationship choices?
approved of by others around you?
- Additional adult abusive relationships. You may find1. Avoid going to extremes. Neither isolation or
yourself in other abusive relationships: with friends,premature, instant attachment are healthy for you.
romantic partners or even helping professionals.Learn to share of yourself with people in your life
How does this happen? How do survivors wind up ingradually, over time.
unhealthy relationships and what can be done about2. Learn to hear and pay attention to your "inner
it?voice". This could be your intuition, your gut sense of
Imago relationship theory suggests that we wind upsomething feeling not quite right with another person.
repeating early relationship dynamics because we areThis could also be the voices of other parts of you.
drawn to potential partners who are an amalgam ofDo not discount what they have to say without
the significant characteristics (positive and negative)exploring it. Yes, some parts may have the job of
of our early caretakers. This explains why children ofwarning you away from anyone, but there may be
alcoholics so often wind up partnering with alcoholicsvalid reason for concerns about an individual in your
themselves as adults, for example. This is notlife.
completely bad news: the theory also holds that3. Get to know yourselves. Develop relationships with
picking someone who fits this "imago" gives us theother parts of yourself. Learn to communicate with
unique opportunity to work through our woundingeach other. Share information about people you are
and achieve a different outcome. However, thismeeting, developing friendships or intimate
requires that we are aware enough of our ownrelationships with.
issues, ready and able to work on them and that our4. Do you already have someone in your life you
imago choice is not also abusive. Instead of healingtrust? A friend? A therapist? Use them as a sounding
this could lead to re-enacting the abuse experiencesboard or reality check. Share what concerns you.
with resulting additional traumatization.Listen to feedback, especially if you tend to "forget"
Attachment theory addresses the vulnerabilitiesthings that concerned you regarding the new
abuse survivors face when attempting to form laterperson's behavior.
relationships. Bessel A. van der Kolk, MD describes a5. Remember that trust is something that is earned.
"vulnerability to traumatic bonding" for those severelyTrust is built in relationships by experiencing each
abused in childhood:other over time. Pay attention to whether what
"People who are exposed early to violence or neglectothers say and do matches up (or does not), look
come to expect it as a way of life. They see thefor consistency over time. Let yourself evaluate
chronic helplessness of their mothers and fathers'whether the relationship is mutual or one sided: do
alternating outbursts of affection and violence; theyyou each get a chance to talk, receive support and
learn that they themselves have no control. As adultsattention 0or does it seem to flow in one direction
they hope to undo the past by love, competency,mostly?
and exemplary behavior. When they fail they are6. Learn how to sort out whether your reactions are
likely to make sense out of this situation by blamingpresent- or past-based. Are you angry because
themselves. When they have little experience withsomeone has violated your boundaries now or are
nonviolent resolution of differences, partners inyou reminded of past experiences? Sometimes it is
relationships alternate between an expectation ofboth!
perfect behavior leading to perfect harmony and a